What is Fee-Only Financial Planning Anyway - and Why Should You Care?
Financial advisors generally use one of three broad compensation structures:
1. Fee-Only: The advisor is paid directly by the client and no one else. That compensation may take the form of an hourly rate, a flat or ongoing fee, or a percentage of assets under management (an AUM fee). Fee-only advisors do not accept commissions or other compensation from third parties. They typically operate as fiduciaries, meaning they are legally obligated to act in their clients’ best interests at all times.
2. Fee-Based: The advisor charges a direct fee for advice but may also earn commissions from selling products such as insurance policies, mutual funds, or annuities. This can result in a somewhat confusing “wearing two hats” situation where an advisor may be under a fiduciary standard when giving planning advice but may be held to a lesser standard when selling products.
3. Commission-Based: The advisor is paid by third parties rather than directly by clients for selling specific financial products. Compensation may come from mutual fund sales loads, insurance premiums, 12b-1 fees, or similar sources. These arrangements usually fall under a suitability standard where the product sold can’t be unsuitable for a client but isn’t required to be in their best interest.
Why is a fee-only compensation model so important to me and why should it matter to you if you’re looking for a financial advisor? Well, as Charlie Munger once said, “Show me the incentive and I’ll show you the outcome.” To illustrate, let’s walk through a quick thought experiment.
Imagine you’re generally healthy, but you’re willing to pay out of pocket for a physician whose job is to help maintain or improve your health and catch problems early. You’re interviewing two doctors: Dr. A and Dr. B.
(Yes, I know this isn’t how paying for medical care works - it’s a thought experiment!)
Dr. A doesn’t charge anything up front for appointments. He has expensive testing equipment in his office and charges you à la carte for every diagnostic. He is paid by pharmaceutical companies for prescribing medications (more for some than others) and receives referral fees for sending you to specialists, some of whom pay higher fees than others. You, of course, also pay for the medications and specialist visits yourself.
Dr. B has a different model. She charges an ongoing retainer fee that increases as your health improves and decreases if your health declines. Anything that can be done in-house is included in that fee. She can refer you to specialists, prescribe medication, and send you for diagnostic testing. You’re still responsible for paying those providers or the pharmacy, but she doesn’t receive any kickbacks. Her only source of compensation is the fee you pay her.
Which doctor would you choose?
I know who I would pick. There isn’t enough information here to say for sure who would cost more, but I’d expect Dr. A is more likely to prescribe expensive medications, perform diagnostic tests, or refer you to specialists, even when those steps may not be necessary. Dr. B, on the other hand, may prescribe a less expensive but equally effective generic and recommend tests or specialist visits only when they’re likely to improve your health or prevent a problem. Dr. B for the win.
You don’t choose a doctor based on cost alone. Which of these two doctors would you trust more to put your interests first? Dr. B benefits only when you get the outcome you want (better health) while Dr. A’s medical decisions may be influenced by which treatment option or diagnostic generates the highest income. For that reason, I would place more trust in Dr. B.
If you’re like me, you’re not a doctor, and much of what you know about medicine comes from watching House and scaring yourself by looking up symptoms on WebMD. But your health is too important to get wrong. At some point, you have to rely on an expert’s judgment and the value of trust in that situation can’t be overstated.
Managing your finances may not be as consequential as managing your health, but it’s still important. Unless you’re a financial professional, it can be difficult to keep up with changing rules, markets, and best practices and then determine what it all means for your specific individual situation. It can be unfamiliar and the stakes can be high. As with the doctor analogy, you have to place your trust in an expert.
So, getting back to what fee-only means and why it matters:
Fee-only means I’m paid much like Dr. B. I charge clients a percentage of the assets I manage. My fee goes up only when those assets grow, whether through investment performance, additional client savings, or clients choosing to move more assets under my management because I’m doing a good job.
Other fee-only advisors may structure their fees differently. Flat, one-time, hourly, and ongoing fees are all common. But the basic idea is the same: the only compensation we receive comes from our clients, so our incentive is to do a good job for them. We aren’t paid by third parties whose interests may not align with those of our clients.
To me, it was a no brainer to structure my fees this way when I started Mindi. I’m in this business to help people and I only want to be rewarded for providing advice and investment management that leave my clients better off.
If this post has left you with more questions than answers about how your current advisor is compensated, let’s talk. Schedule a complimentary introductory call to learn more about how working with a fee-only financial planner is different.